top of page

Ways A Defendant Can Contest Liability In A New York Car Accident Claim

Car Accident Attorneys | New York | Law Office of Dimitrios Kourouklis, Ph.D.

If someone else’s negligence caused your New York motor vehicle accident, the at-fault party’s insurance company typically holds the purse strings when it comes to settlements. The insurance companies are big businesses, and they do not make money by paying out large sums of money on personal injury claims. Instead, in most case cases, the insurance companies will try to pin some—or all—of the blame on the injured victim for causing the accident. For example, the insurance company may allege that you drove carelessly or recklessly or that you somehow caused or contributed to the motor vehicle collision. Even under these circumstances, though, you may still recover monetary compensation for the personal injuries and damages you sustained in the accident.

The knowledgeable personal injury lawyers at Law Office of Dimitrios Kourouklis, Ph.D. know and understand the tricks that insurance companies routinely use to try to limit their liability and exposure in personal injury cases. Our attorneys are ready and willing to take on insurance companies and fight any liability disputes that their adjusters raise. Our knowledgeable team of attorneys can investigate and evaluate your claim and may help you obtain the monetary compensation you need and deserve.

Common Causes of New York Motor Vehicle Accidents

Thanks to busy highways and congested roads, aggressive driving has unfortunately become all-too-common on roadways throughout New York City and New York State. When motor vehicle drivers engage in aggressive, reckless, or careless driving, they jeopardize the safety and well-being of all other drivers on the roadways at that time. Negligent driving may include:

  • Abrupt lane changes

  • Failing to come to a complete stop at a stop sign

  • Running or trying to beat a light that is changing

  • Running a red light

  • Weaving in and out of highway traffic

  • Tailgating

  • Failing to use appropriate turn signals

  • Exceeding posted speed limits

  • Distracted driving (e.g. texting while driving or using a cell phone that lacks a hands-free option)

  • Driving while under the influence of alcohol or drugs (DUI)

  • Fatigued driving

Proving the At-Fault Driver Was Negligent For Your Accident

New York drivers owe all other drivers on the roadways an affirmative duty to operate their motor vehicles in reasonably safe, prudent, and careful ways under the circumstances. In other words, New York drivers have a duty to carefully obey all New York traffic laws and rules of the road while operating their vehicles.

To recover damages for personal injuries sustained in an accident that a negligent driver caused, the injured accident victim has the burden of proving that the aggressive driver behaved in a reckless, careless, or negligent manner, or otherwise breached the applicable standard of care. The injured accident victim must also prove the accident directly resulted in serious injuries, as defined under New York Insurance Law, and damages.

Denying or Limiting Liability

In New York personal injury cases, insurance companies and their adjusters will do everything in their powers to limit the accident victim’s monetary recovery and damages, or they may deny liability (or fault for the accident) altogether. They do this by alleging that the injured accident victim caused or contributed to the accident. Some jurisdictions outside of New York take extremely unforgiving views when it comes to contributory negligence. Those jurisdictions completely bar an injured accident victim from obtaining any monetary recovery if a jury finds that the accident victim caused or contributed to the accident in any way—no matter how slight the percentage of fault on the part of the injured driver. An injured driver may contribute to their accident by speeding, engaging in distracted driving, or running a red light, for example.

Fortunately, instead of applying this harsh doctrine of contributory negligence, New York State uses a pure comparative fault standard. Under this standard, the injured plaintiff who is partially to blame for causing a motor vehicle accident reduces the amount of potential monetary recovery by an amount equal to the plaintiff’s percentage of fault for causing the accident.

By way of example, if the plaintiff traveled five miles per hour more than the speed limit and the jury ultimately found the plaintiff was 5 percent at fault for the accident (and that the other driver was 95 percent at fault), then the plaintiff’s available damages will reduce by 5 percent. In theory, under this system of recovery, a plaintiff could still receive some slight recovery, even if a jury found the plaintiff 99 percent at fault for the motor vehicle accident. A court may deem a Plaintiff (injured driver) fully or partially responsible for an accident for:

  • Failing to use a turn signal

  • Speeding

  • Swerving

  • Stopping too quickly in front of another vehicle

  • Failing to maintain the proper driving distance

  • Running a red traffic light, stop sign, or yield sign

  • Failing to properly yield the right-of-way to another vehicle

  • Operating a vehicle while intoxicated or while under the influence of drugs

Potential Damages Available to Car Accident Victims

An injured motor vehicle accident victim may still recover both economic and noneconomic damages when partially at-fault for the accident. In this case, damages may include monetary compensation for medical bills and expenses, physical therapy costs, lost wages for time missed from work, pain and suffering, mental anguish and emotional distress, loss of earning capacity, loss of companionship, and loss of spousal support.

Contact a New York Car Accident Attorney Today to Discuss Your Case

Someone else’s negligence can cause potentially serious and lifelong personal injuries in a New York car accident. Even if the court deems you, the accident victim, partially responsible for the accident, the law may still entitle you to some (or all) of your available damages.

Our team of attorneys is always available to answer your questions. We are very responsive to phone calls and emails 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year. Our team will work swiftly, efficiently, and aggressively to meet your needs and to obtain a favorable result for you and to assist you with fighting liability disputes that are raised by the at fault driver and the insurance company.

The New York Car Accident Attorneys at the Law Office of Dimitrios Kourouklis, Ph.D offer free initial consultations to discuss your rights and to evaluate your claim. You can contact us at 929-400-7608 or via email. Do not hesitate. Time may be of the essence.

Featured Posts
Recent Posts
Search By Tags
bottom of page